Execute synthetic peer-review process on EoE de novo binder-design manuscript (EoE_manuscript.md and EoE_supplementary.md) using the synthetic-peer-review skill. Evaluate in-silico computational design study with disclosed AI authorship as hackathon deliverable, focusing on computational methodology and design validation rather than experimental validation.
This session set out to run a synthetic peer-review process on an in-silico de novo binder-design manuscript for eosinophilic esophagitis (EoE), evaluating the computational methodology and design validation of a disclosed AI-authored hackathon deliverable rather than experimental results.
The agent applied a synthetic-peer-review skill to the manuscript and supplementary files (EoE_manuscript.md and EoE_supplementary.md), producing a peer review report and a revision plan, then generated revised versions of the manuscript and supplement along with supporting analyses such as decoy control results/calibration and Chai-Boltz concordance data. It also drafted a point-by-point response to reviewers and a decoy-control memo explaining the concordance checks. Finally, all markdown deliverables were converted into Word documents using a python-docx-based converter (since pandoc was unavailable), with embedded figures and tables, and the agent verified image/table counts in each output file.
Key deliverables include the revised manuscript and supplement (EoE_manuscript_revised.docx with 7 embedded figures; EoE_supplementary_revised.docx with 14 figures and a Methods table), plus response_to_reviewers.docx and decoy_control_memo.docx documenting the review response and decoy/concordance analysis. Supporting data and source files (peer_review_report.md/docx, revision_plan.md, chai_boltz_concordance.csv, decoy_control_results.csv, TableS6_concordance_and_controls.csv, and editable .md originals) were also produced.
Artifacts (17)
| File | Type | Size | |
|---|---|---|---|
| π | chai_boltz_concordance.csv | Data | 16 KB |
| π | decoy_control_results.csv | Data | 8 KB |
| π | decoy_control_spec.csv | Data | 5 KB |
| π | TableS6_concordance_and_controls.csv | Data | 8 KB |
| π | decoy_control_memo.docx | Document | 40 KB |
| π | EoE_manuscript_revised.docx | Document | 2.3 MB |
| π | EoE_supplementary_revised.docx | Document | 1.6 MB |
| π | peer_review_report.docx | Document | 36 KB |
| π | response_to_reviewers.docx | Document | 39 KB |
| πΌ | chai_concordance.png | Figure | 96 KB |
| πΌ | decoy_calibration.png | Figure | 111 KB |
| π | decoy_control_memo.md | Text | 7 KB |
| π | EoE_manuscript_revised.md | Text | 37 KB |
| π | EoE_supplementary_revised.md | Text | 11 KB |
| π | peer_review_report.md | Text | 59 KB |
| π | response_to_reviewers.md | Text | 5 KB |
| π | revision_plan.md | Text | 11 KB |